Opting Out of Cancer and Into Molestation
If you don't fly, then great. Your protest options are simple. You can just continue not flying as a form of dissent with the new airport security screening procedures. Easy peasy.
If you have to fly, and if you can possibly stomach it, please consider requesting a pat down when you go through security vs. being scanned by the machine. The official word is that they are supposed to pat your legs up to your crotch, or as they say, "Until they meet resistance." (By "resistance," I don't think they mean the traveler's loud objections.) And for women this will include touching the breasts. (This does little more than remind me of my visits to Madison Square Garden for performances, something I quickly stopped doing because of the obnoxious security screening, but that's another gripe for another day.) You are allowed to request that the screening be done in private, but personally I feel much safer having my fellow travelers there as witnesses. I'm sure there are and will continue to be some jerk TSA people out there who handle this in a less-than-professional manner, which worries me, but I still consider this the safer alternative to radiation. Yes, they say the amount of radiation is tiny, but the thing for me is that scientists still aren't sure if the effects of radiation are cumulative. And no reasonable doctor I've heard of believes there is a truly "safe" amount of radiation. They recommend against pregnant women being scanned, so how can I possibly be expected to send my children through that machine? Anyway, I'm hoping the presence of adorable twins at least gains me some sympathy in the pat-down line. Although I wonder how the TSA feels about cloth diapers?
Moving on, the reason the pat down is being considered a means of protest is that TSA is not very well equipped to handle large numbers of people requesting pat downs. One official openly expressed concern about the planned November 24th Opt Out protest. You can also call or write your senators. There will be a Senate hearing on this topic tomorrow.
If you are able to rearrange your life accordingly, then you can definitely protest by not flying at all. Or if you have some extra money to spend on the problem, you can show up for a flight and then make a scene at the airport security checkpoint, although due to regulations I consider to be pretty fucking stupid, you can be fined for entering the security zone and then failing to complete the security check. Given that the TSA has not been particularly forthcoming with the details of the various screening options, I find this rule to be pretty sleazy. Hell, I find the whole thing to be sleazy.
For me, while I'm annoyed about this and plan to express my displeasure about these procedures, I do find the whole airport security frenzy to be a joke. I'm not convinced these increased measures do much to deter terrorists. Maybe they'll keep future shoe bombers and the like off planes, but the serious fellows will always find a way, won't they? I get so tired of being treated like a criminal every time I want to fly or cross a border. But even this is not as bad as the triple-screening we got in Dubai or this one time in France. And it's certainly not as scary as some of the border crossings we've done, when you know you can be snatched out of the world in a second just for wearing the wrong expression on your face. But perhaps I should reserve judgment until I've had my first pat down.
Tuesday, November 16, 2010
Labels:
Mixed Nuts,
We Go Places
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
Our Thanksgiving protest will be easy, though. In fact, I'll just go ahead and say we'll protest every Thanksgiving, since we always spend that holiday at home.
One last thing. It probably won't make any difference, but you can also leave a comment on the TSA's blog:
http://blog.tsa.gov/2010/11/new-tsa-pat-down-procedures.html
An email from a friend made me feel a little worried that after this post, and especially given the title (which was intended to be a gross exaggeration of the truth) people will think I'm saying the scanners have crazy high radiation and will definitely give you cancer. Of course not. Do your own research and make your own decisions. Read the FDA report, and then go read the studies, and then go learn more about radiation so that you can start to understand all of the other stuff you just read. I didn't post all of that stuff because I don't really consider that part of my job as a casual blogger, and I don't want to seem like I'm trying to play the part of scientific expert. All I'm saying is that until doctors and scientists are sure it's really fine and are willing to send pregnant women through, I'm not sending my babies or my ovaries through there repeatedly for the rest of my life when there's a reasonable alternative.
While I'm lazy and am looking forward to the speed of mechanical X-ray vision, I salute you on taking an informed stand on the issue.
If we ever travel together I'll wait for you after security and support your decision.
I have been getting the pat downs for 7 years. I have implants in my spinal cord and cannot go through the traditional scanners they've been using for years.
Male agents pat down men, Female agents pat down women. I've flown anywhere from 4-15 times a year for the past 7 years getting pat downs and have always found the agents to be professional, kind and understanding. This includes agents from many states, Florida to IL to CA to NV to Washington state. Really, it's no big deal at all. Seriously.
I've also gone through the new scanners (yeah! I don't mind pat downs but it usually takes a while to get a female officer over to do it) The scanners are quick and fine.
I've checked with many docs I work with and they say it's no worse than an xray. While preg women shouldn't get x-rays, kids can. You just shouldn't get one every day of the week.
Interestingly, if the TSA didn't institute these new measures and a bomb got on a plane, people would shout "you should have done more." They do do more and people shout "invasion of privacy."
That said, people need to do what they are comfortable with.
I really do wonder what they'll do with cloth diapers! We'll be flying with my daughter in a few months. Will the TSA consider any soiled diapers to be fluid or gel-like? Will they decide to hand-inspect them? This is a new wrench to throw into the travel-with-baby plans!
Post a Comment