Thursday, May 20, 2010

No "Ma'am"

These days it seems as though the good residents of Internetland are reading my mind. A few days ago, I wandered over to Dooce and came across this. I can tell you we've gone round and round on that one. How do we want our children to address people? This is no easy question for someone who was born in the South and lived most of her adult life in the North. (Yes, there are differences.) And who knows where we'll be going next?

I think we basically have come to the same conclusion: that we'll be teaching our children to call people what they wish to be called. To start out with Mr. and Ms.--we don't do Mrs. in this house--until asked to use some other name. To convey respect in the tone of their voices and the calmness of their demeanor. (That "calm" thing will not be taught by me, obviously, but by their father.) We feel like it can't hurt to err on the side of politeness. That said, "ma'am" and "sir" can sound snarky to people who aren't familiar and comfortable with those forms of address. Even though I grew up in the South, it catches me off guard anytime I'm addressed as "ma'am." Who you callin' ma'am, SIR?

Anyway, all this to say that I'm glad I'm not the only person who struggles with choosing which bits of etiquette to teach my children. When you have lived in one geographic area for your entire life, it's natural to just adopt the customs that you are familiar with. But for those of us who are known migrants, it's a bit more challenging. For instance, when we move back to the South, I'll have to remember not to go around kissing everyone.



Ah, but this reminds me of one of the many American customs that I do miss very much: the hug. Something to look forward to.

4 comments:

Parco Moon said...

We're very big on Ma'am and Sir, and every adult gets called Mr. or Ms. + their first name or their last name, depending on that person's personal preference. But all that would be viewed as weird in Pennsylvania, I'm sure.

Stockyard Queen said...

So if a woman wants to be called Mrs., will you allow that?

FiveSevenFive said...

I'm a huge fan of politeness, and I think that good manners have really fallen by the wayside. Granted, I was always resentful of having to ask "may I be excused from the table?" after meals, but it built character. And gave me ample material for finger-wagging moments as an adult. I like the idea of going with Mr./Ms./Mrs./Miss or whatever the person prefers to be called.

That being said, I sincerely hope your children will call me "Crazy Auntie 5-7-5."

Coma Divine said...

I was raised to call every parent Mr. or Mrs. so-and-so. Call it old fashion, but it kind of throws me for a loop when I hear my friends address my dad as "Mark", or even my friend's parents request that they be called by their first names.

Just go with the ubiquitous Mr. & Ms/Mrs. rule, and they'll learn to improv. as necessary.